August 1, 2014
Seventeen-year-old Ashe Douglas records the events of 1968 in a novel in haiku. Ashe was born on May 17, 1951, and is a senior in high school during the year he decides to describe in haiku, liking the tidiness of the three-line, 17-syllable form. The year is 1968, when more soldiers died in the Vietnam War than in any other year. Ashe decides not only to write haiku, but to dedicate a syllable to each soldier killed-976 haiku equals 16,592 syllables equals the number of soldiers killed in 1968. An entire story "contained by a syllable count." Not only is that asking a lot of its diminutive form, but so much happened in 1968: the war, race riots, the assassinations of Martin Luther King Jr. and Robert F. Kennedy, let alone Ashe's family life, which resembles a war zone. Haiku stanzas just can't contain it all, being ill equipped for the depth or context necessary for a rich historical novel. But what transcends contrivance and gimmickry is Ashe's voice, and haiku are well-suited to carry that. With newspaper headlines, death tolls, and overwhelming world, national and domestic events in the background, one boy's clear and earnest voice records his life: "I'll / write what needs to be / remembered and leave it to / you to fill in the gaps." A memorable / and innovative story / of one wrenching year. (historical note, author's note) (Historical fiction/poetry. 12-16)
COPYRIGHT(2014) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
September 1, 2014
Gr 9 Up-It's 1968, and 17-year-old Ashe Douglas is coping with two devastating wars: one in Vietnam and one in his own home. His parents married young after his mother became pregnant with him and have been sticking it out in a loveless marriage for his sake ever since. The two are fiercely incompatible with fundamentally different beliefs, and Ashe is caught in the middle. Making matters worse are rising casualties in Vietnam and increasing racial and political unrest, all of which have a profound impact on Ashe and those he loves and which threaten to snap the delicate threads holding his life together. Written entirely in stanzas of haiku, the novel is composed of 16,592 syllables, one for each American soldier killed in Vietnam in 1968. This structure, while meaningful, somewhat limits the pacing and full development of the story, and the characters, at times, feel like caricatures of the era. Still, Ashe's emotional struggle is heartbreaking, and his story gives Crowe a thoughtful platform from which to explore issues of family, divorce, patriotism, peace, human compassion, and the tolls of war. It will appeal to fans of novels in verse or to readers with an interest in the Vietnam War, Civil Rights, or American history.-Lauren Strohecker, McKinley Elementary School, Abington School District, PA
Copyright 2014 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
October 15, 2014
Grades 9-12 In 1968, the weekly American death count in Vietnam was a regular TV news announcement; the civil rights movement made strides and lost leaders; and adults were choosing sides between the Silent Generation and the new activist one. Crowe weaves all these salient details into a novel composed entirely in haiku stanzas (though the lines all together form complete sentences and dialogue), with a syllable for every American soldier's death that year. Seventeen-year-old Ashe writes of his senior year in high school and his tense family life, dominated by his parents' loveless marriage, as well as conflicting attitudes from his new girlfriend and his civics teacher about the growing realities of war and the changing depth of the political field at home. All the while, he tries to shape an opinion of his own that fulfills his needs and those of the people around him. The unusual narrative style makes this exploration of Vietnam-era politics at home and abroad readily accessible to struggling readers, while fans of poetry may appreciate the eloquence in its brevity.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2014, American Library Association.)
January 1, 2015
Crowe's novel in haiku respectfully acknowledges each of the 16,592 soldiers who died in the Vietnam War in 1968 by using that exact number of syllables in this work. The story showcases a melodramatic breakdown of seventeen-year-old narrator Ashe's home life and his parents' marriage. Though the historical and fictional dilemmas may resonate, supporting characters tend toward stereotypical political ideologues of the time.
(Copyright 2015 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)