I Want a Better Catastrophe

Starred review from December 15, 2022
Envisioning the planet's dire future. Writer, humorist, and longtime activist Boyd describes himself as a "tragic optimist," "can-do pessimist," and "compassionate nihilist" when he considers efforts to reverse or mitigate environmental devastation. His "can-do" spirit led to his joining many activist groups and launching the Climate Clock, which "counts down the time remaining to prevent global warming rising above 1.5�C (currently six and a half years and closing), while simultaneously tracking our progress on key solution pathways (renewable energy, Indigenous land sovereignty, and others)." Realizing, though, that others may be so overcome with despair that activism seems futile, he offers this book as "a small head start on the grieving process--and some help answering the question, What is still worth doing?" An appendix lists nearly 40 organizations with which readers can engage. Boyd includes interviews with eight "hopers and doomers," including Robin Wall Kimmerer, who explain their responses to the crisis. Climate scientist Guy McPherson predicts human extinction; eco-Buddhist Joanna Macy entitled her book Active Hope. Gopal Dayaneni, co-founder of the think tank Movement Generation, debunks the "Green scenario" because it "allows us to indulge the fiction that we can technologically innovate our way out of the crisis; that progress is inevitable." Psychoanalyst Jamey Hecht believes it is possible "to know the worst and still be happy." Boyd cautiously concurs: "While it's too late to prevent catastrophe, if we step up our game, we can still build a new, more decent society on the ashes of the old." All of the author's evidence points to the inadequacy of capitalism and politics. Individual actions--recycling, a plant-based diet, biking and walking rather than driving--are not useless, but community is crucial for meaningful change. "We not only have the capacity to transform the world towards greater equity, justice, diversity, and integrity," Gopal tells Boyd, but "if you look around, you'll see that we are actually exercising that capacity everywhere." Urgent, sobering reading.

COPYRIGHT(2022) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.